Showing posts with label language. Show all posts
Showing posts with label language. Show all posts

Tuesday, 8 July 2008

SBL in Auckland - Tuesday lunch

Several of us are at SBL International conference in Auckland this week. If has been good fun so far. There are heaps of Aussies here (the majority of delegates I'd guess) and lots of people various ones of us know from different places. Like all conferences of this sort some papers are better and more stimulating than others.

My favourites so far have been a paper by Mervyn Duffy on the place of language in Eden, and one by Peter Lockwood from the Lutheran College in Adelaide arguing that the narrator of Judges in sensitive to some of the ethical problems of the conquest and builds a case to "qualify, modify and justify" the violence of his account. Mervyn's paper was stimulated by a claim by the modern Catholic theologian Chauvet that Augustine and Aquinas suggest that there is no place for language in the garden of Eden. Chauvet sees this as an example the classical metaphysics (or onto-theology) of the tradition and he opposes this with a view which see reality as constituted by language all the way down. Mervyn was arguing that the tradition has a stronger place for language than Chauvet allows. He pointed to some material in both Augustine and Aquinas which go some way to demonstrating this, though I was not convinced that their Neoplatonism does not have more of an effect on their views. 

I'll try to mention a few other papers later today, but now I am off to do my own paper on Pannenberg.

Monday, 9 June 2008

Christian language

For our discussions about our faith, we use some words not in general use (like “sanctification”) and invest some words with specialised meanings (like “justification”). In this, we are following the example of the Biblical writers who coined new words and added freight to others, and are no different from many other sub-groups in having some in-house language.

Where it becomes a problem is when we persist in using our jargon and redefinitions beyond our sub-group, and particularly when we adopt a condescending attitude to “outsiders” who don’t use words in the “proper” way. “Church” is people, not building, right? The problem is that in the wider linguistic community of which we are a subset, one of the meanings of church is a building, and it seems counterproductive not to recognise this.

The word I really want to blog about is “Christian”. Our sub-culture wants to be more or less restrictive in its application of the term. I was once told that there were only two or three Christians in a congregation I was about to pastor. This narrower definition of Christian is at odds with what our language community generally understands by the term.

More than this, it is not even one that we can find Biblical warrant for. The word “Christian” (at least in those versions which transliterate the Greek Christianos) is found only three times in the New Testament (Acts 11:26, Acts 26:28 and 1 Pet 4:16). Modelled on the pattern we see, e.g., in “Herodian”, it is used, as we see from the Acts 11:26 reference, to apply to the “disciples” (followers and learners) of the one acknowledged as the “Christ”. To understand who are included in the category of “disciples”, we could turn to Matt 28:19-20 where discipleship begins with the expression of commitment in baptism and continues with instruction in obedience to Christ’s commandments. That, I take it, was true of all of the members of the congregation I pastored. While I and all Christians have a lot more discipleship ahead of us — a lot more working through the implications of our commitment, a lot more learning, a lot more growing in obedience — I don’t believe that we can meaningfully or helpfully deny the term to any who so wish to acknowledge and be identified with the name of Christ.